Bring the Bottle

Watercolor-style illustration of a server decanting red wine at a candlelit table for two in a wood-paneled restaurant, an older couple smiling as they watch. Below it: Vianarra. Bring the Bottle. Why I pay the corkage and carry my own wine to dinner. Patrick R. Dunn.

A few months ago, I took an older Napa Cabernet out of my cellar for an anniversary dinner in Reno and carried it into the restaurant in my hand. When the server came to the table and saw the label, his face changed. He'd been wanting to taste that vintage for months and had never had the chance. He decanted it slowly at the side station, swapped the glasses on the table for better ones, and between courses he kept coming back, not to sell us anything, but to ask how it was opening up. We spent two hours with that bottle, and by the end of the night the man pouring it had become part of the dinner. The corkage was thirty dollars.

I've thought about that night often, because most of my restaurant dinners haven't gone that way, and I doubt most people's have either. The usual routine is to open the list, skip past the bottles because they cost more than the entrée, and order a glass of the house red. It comes out a little warm, poured from a bottle that may have been open since yesterday, and it tastes like nothing in particular. Nobody at the table asks where it came from, and the server couldn't tell you if they did, because the wine was chosen for the margin and not for the meal. Industry convention is to charge the bottle's wholesale price for a single glass, so the restaurant has its money back on the first pour, which works out to roughly a 400 percent markup. Restaurants have real overhead, and wine is where many of them make their living, so I don't hold that against them. What I mind is spending fifty dollars on two glasses that nobody will remember by the drive home.

A bottle you bring with you is a different thing on the table. Somebody picked it, for a reason and for that night, and it came from somewhere that can be named. Where the law allows it, many restaurants will open your own bottle for a corkage fee, usually $15 to $50, and for that you still get the glasses, the pour and the service you'd get from their own list. The arithmetic works out better than people expect. A $60 bottle from a wine shop cost the shop around $43 wholesale, and on a restaurant list the same wine would sell for about $120. Poured by the glass at the bottle's wholesale cost per pour, four glasses would come to more than $170. Carried in yourself with a $25 corkage fee, it costs $85.

You don't need a cellar to do this, and you don't need to know much about wine. Walk into a wine shop, tell whoever is working what you're having for dinner, and ask what they'd open with it. The best bottles to bring are the ones with a story you can tell at the table. For a pasta night with red sauce, I'd look for a Barbera from Amador County. It's Piedmont's everyday red, the wine northern Italian families drink with dinner, and the warm Sierra foothills have turned out to suit it. It has enough acidity to stand up to the tomatoes. For roast chicken or a piece of salmon, a Russian River Valley Pinot Noir carries the fog that rolls up that valley from the Pacific most summer mornings. For a steak or a night that matters, bring an old-vine Zinfandel from Amador or Dry Creek Valley, from vines that in some cases were in the ground before anyone at the table was born. Once someone asks where it's from, the dinner is about more than the food.

There are a few courtesies that keep the arrangement fair. Call ahead to ask about the restaurant's policy and fee, and don't bring a wine they already carry. If the bottle is an older red, stand it upright for a day or two so the sediment settles, carry it gently, and leave the foil and cork on until it reaches the table. If it's white or sparkling, chill it at home so the kitchen isn't scrambling. Offer a taste to whoever pours it, and tip as if you'd bought the bottle from them, because they opened it and kept your glass full all night.

That server in Reno never sold us a thing. He went home that night having tasted a wine he'd wanted to try for months, and we went home talking about him.

Sources: The anniversary dinner is my own. Restaurant pricing conventions, by-the-glass markups and typical corkage fees from Toast's restaurant wine markup guide, VinePair, Punch, Vinology and MEL Magazine. Retail store markups from the Franklin County Times. The $60 bottle example is my own arithmetic from those figures.

Stories like this one, every week

Vianarra Insights goes to hospitality people on Wednesdays. Vianarra Wine & Travel goes to wine lovers every other Friday. Both are free.

Subscribe free Read Wine & Travel

Staff Workshops Book a Tasting

About the author

Patrick R. Dunn is a wine and travel journalist based in Sparks, Nevada, and the founder of Vianarra. He trained in narrative under Stephen King and folklorist Edward "Sandy" Ives at the University of Maine, spent more than a decade as a National Park Service interpretive ranger at six sites, and spent thirty years leading global crisis management and operational resilience teams across four continents. He holds the WSET Level 3 Award in Wines, is a member of the International Food, Wine & Travel Writers Association and the North American Travel Journalists Association, and is the author of Stop Leading on Empty.

Subscribe to Vianarra Insights and Vianarra Wine & Travel.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top