Meet the Winemakers: Tor Kenward
TOR Wines, St. Helena. Recorded on Zoom, November 18, 2026.

In 2016, two lots of grapes arrived at a Napa Valley winery on the same day. One was Cabernet Sauvignon, the other Petit Verdot, both from Vine Hill Ranch. Jeff Ames, the winemaker, wanted to put them in the same tank. Forty percent Petit Verdot. Tor Kenward, who owned the winery and had spent nearly forty years in the Napa Valley wine business, told him no. There was too much money at stake, and nobody made a wine that way.
Ames kept asking. He even enlisted other winemakers to argue his case. Kenward eventually gave in. Whatever happened next would be something they would have to live with, and there was no separating the grapes once they were in the tank.
Nearly fifty years after arriving in Napa Valley, Kenward still talks about the people who taught him, the decisions he got wrong, and the wines that surprised him. Some of those surprises came from the people he was supposed to be teaching.
Kenward arrived in Napa in the 1970s, when there were fewer than fifty wineries in the valley and a visitor could walk into a tasting room and find the owner behind the counter. He had come north from Santa Barbara, where friends at a jazz club he helped run had introduced him to great European wines. In Napa, Joe Heitz and André Tchelistcheff poured wines for him and talked about what they knew. He joined Beringer in 1977 and stayed until 2001, when he and his wife, Susan, started TOR Wines. Along the way, he became part of the generation that helped turn a relatively obscure California wine region into one of the most recognized in the world.
His father, a playwright, named him after High Tor, a Maxwell Anderson play about a man who refuses to sell his mountain to a quarry company. The name eventually found its way onto the family’s wine label. Kenward has written about his years in Napa in Reflections of a Vintner, but some of the most interesting stories are still the ones he tells about other people.
He remembers the teachers who opened doors for him, the young people who came through those doors, and the vintages that taught him something he couldn’t have learned any other way. He remembers the harvest of 2020, when smoke cost TOR an entire vintage of red wine. And after nearly fifty years, he says he sometimes feels he knows less about winemaking than he did when he started.
These are his answers to the twenty questions every winemaker in this series is asked, plus one more.
1.Who taught you?
When I came to Napa in the mid-'70s, the doors were pretty much wide open, and when I started working at Beringer they opened even wider. André Tchelistcheff always had an open door. I spent a couple of meals with him talking about wine in the early days, and I wrote about one of them in the book. It shaped my thinking about the ageability of Napa wines. There was Joe Heitz.
Beringer hired a lot of European talent, thinking we could learn from the Old World. I worked with Patrick Léon as a mentor at Beringer, before he went to Opus, trying to get us to understand Cabernet in particular, and the cinq cépages. Along with him there was Jean-Louis Mandrau, who had worked at Château Latour. Patrick Léon had worked at Mouton. We were owned by Nestlé at the time, so we had access to some of the more interesting consultants from Europe.
Of the mentors I had here at home, again there was André, and Myron Nightingale, who I worked with at Beringer. And somebody who keeps popping up in our history is Maynard Amerine, who lived in St. Helena and would invite me up to his house for tastings. He was very exacting about how he conducted a tasting, but an amazing man who contributed a lot. I think the gestalt of Maynard Amerine is still viable now.
Early on there was also Rich Thomas, who taught viticulture at the JC. He was a real character. He let me take a lot of classes and somehow got me a degree while I was working full time at Beringer, and he knew everybody in Sonoma. He invited me as a schlepper to one of the big Sonoma tastings at the fair, and André was one of the judges. I spent some time with André then, and we stayed in touch. André was decisive in making a 1974 Petite Sirah from Trentadue the sweepstakes winner that year. I saved a few bottles of that wine. I might still have one.
2.Who have you taught, and where are they now?
Somewhat like André, I've liked to consider the door, or the email door, or the phone call, always open. So when you ask that question, it really is a lot of people over a lot of time, always there when they wanted direction from me or thought I could contribute something to their questions about the wine industry and how they should go forward. When I wrote the book, Reflections of a Vintner, and it went through two printings, a lot of people got back to me that I didn't even realize I had been a mentor to in some ways. So, not to be specific, certainly a lot of people in the wine industry over the years, and sometimes people outside it.
One inside the industry was Tim Hanni. He was working at Happy Herman’s in Atlanta when I talked him into coming to Napa Valley, and he and Joel Butler went on to become the first two Masters of Wine from the United States. He’s been a great teacher. Another, on the chef side, was Gary Danko, who I also brought out from the East Coast. I mentored him into wine and food pairing and opened up a few doors for him. He stayed with us for about six or seven years, and then went on to start Restaurant Gary Danko and a few others. I got very involved with chefs over those years.
3.Is there a vintage you date your life by?
Candidly, I sort of like the vintages that are challenging, like 2011 and 2022. The ones that become challenges, where you really have to apply a lot of experience, are the most memorable. But the ones we're probably best known for, and that I really enjoy retasting when I can, are 2016 and 2018. They continue to amaze me and evolve.
2018 keeps amazing me. It was a fairly big vintage, not one of those shy vintages, and it wasn't a cool year. It was a relatively warm year, but the wines have continued to have magic.
If you go back to my early years, it was 1974, and 1977, which was a drought year and an amazing year. The '80s were mixed, though I'm very fond of '86 for a variety of reasons. '87 is extraordinary. '91 is one of my all-time favorite vintages from Napa Valley.
4.What's changed in the trade since you started that someone new would walk right past?
That's an interesting question. It could go a lot of different directions. One thing that has changed a lot since I started TOR, and it's a departure from my early Beringer days, is the evolution toward direct-to-consumer sales. In my early years, the '70s, '80s, '90s, up to the turn of the century, we were driven by the wholesale world. But in the last twenty years in particular, the shift to direct-to-consumer has been, in my mind anyway, for a winery like mine, a seismic change.
5.Walk me through a typical harvest day at the peak.
Well, there is no typical day. You've got a lot of plates in the air, so I guess that's the one thing that's constant. You're juggling a lot of things. You might have some wines in tank. You might be making decisions about whether you want to do any pre-soaks. You're looking at your fermentation temperatures based on the ripeness levels of what you're picking.
The thing we focus on every single day is picking windows. What are those picking windows? That is as critical a decision as we can possibly make, and a lot of time and energy goes into it. That's tasting the berries, looking at analytics, looking at everything, and then also looking back in history. What did you do under circumstances that might be similar in that particular year? But a lot of it just comes down to what you've got in tank, and what the picking window is for what you haven't picked.
6.What decision do you make that you can't fully explain to someone else?
To a degree, yes, and it comes down to the picking window again. Sometimes you have extreme weather. Let's use 2022 as a classic, or maybe an extreme example. We had that ten-day heat dome, and picking windows under those conditions become extremely difficult. What you have to rely on is past experience, past times when you had weather conditions that replicate it as closely as possible, and what decisions you made back then that were successful and which ones you felt were less successful. That's something that's kind of hard to teach somebody. It's something you almost have to experience, or be in the room with somebody who's gone through it.
7.Tell me about a harvest that went wrong.
2020. That went real wrong. We had fire, of course. We had smoke in the valley from, I think, mid-August all the way through, and what we ended up doing was not picking any of the reds, not taking a gamble on it. It was a huge hit for us in a lot of different ways. It was an interesting dance between us and our growers on how we managed that loss, and it still impacts us today that we lost a full vintage.
8.Who's the legend around the winery?
Jeff Ames, my winemaker. Jeff was part of Thomas Brown's Schrader thing, he was working on TOR in 2001, our first year, and he's been with us since the beginning. Maybe I'm a mentor to Jeff, but Jeff's been a mentor to me in many ways.
Your question about mentors is an interesting one, because I really think that with a lot of the people I mentor or have mentored, I've learned as much from them, sometimes more, than they've learned from me. At least in my case, that mentoring thing is a two-way street.
9.Is there something that happens at the end of crush every year?
A couple of things. One is, and I'm sure you've heard this before, we do party. We open up some old wines, we raid the cellar, and we share a couple of meals together, rejoicing. But something I think is critical is that we sit down as a winemaking team and evaluate the harvest. How was it similar to past harvests? What was different about it? What went wrong? What went right? What's the early prognosis of the vintage? We do a down and dirty, then write up the notes afterward and file them away, so that while it's still fresh in our minds we have an evaluation of the harvest, something we can refer to in later harvests.
10.What do people outside the trade always get wrong?
There are probably a lot of things. The question I get most is, when should I drink this wine? It's one, two, or three of the questions I always get, and what they get wrong is thinking there's one universal, magical date to open a bottle of wine. As experienced wine drinkers know, that's just not true. Everybody's got their own window. Some people like their wines with a lot of fruit, in their youth. Some people like them old. Some people are necrophiliacs. They like dead wines, at least that's what it seems like to us.
What they don't get is that the best thing you can do is find your own drinking window, where you like wines, and start focusing on that and making your decisions based on it. Not what Robert Parker said, not what another wine critic said, but what you feel personally is your drinking window and how you like your wines. Along the same line, we all like and appreciate wines in different ways. So if your way is not the way of a famous wine critic, go your way, not the wine critic's way.
11.What's the first thing you got wrong, and who caught it?
Oh, wow. One was when Jeff and I crossed our communication, and we picked one block a little early and had to live with it. You have two choices. One is to see if it magically fits into a blend and doesn't tear everything down, and if it doesn't do that, you have to sell the wine off. We don't often cross paths or miscommunicate, but that was one time we did, and we ended up having to sell the wine and get rid of it.
Another time was early on, when Thomas Rivers Brown was the head winemaker. For the first two years, Jeff worked underneath him. We loved Rhône varieties, so we made a Syrah, and it came in, as Syrah often does, with a very high pH. Thomas decided to hit it with a little acid, and I have to say that wine never survived that bit of acid. It stayed sinewy, and it still is today. After that, I don't think we ever hit a wine with acid.
12.Is there something you still do the way you were taught, even though a faster way exists?
I think winemaking, at least at the level I'm very fortunate to participate in, which is small production, very focused on vineyards and on blocks within vineyards, is the process of getting to know each block. We try to keep them separate, especially in To Kalon, so we can understand how they perform and how they're different. There's clonal differentiation in To Kalon, so each of those clones performs differently in that vineyard. The blocks perform differently. That's a classic example of what takes time, really understanding how you can possibly maximize those blocks.
That takes in what kind of coopers you're using. What we've found, and I think most of my peers feel the same way, is that some coopers perform much better with certain vineyards than with others. So it takes time to understand your coopers, your vineyards, and your maturity, when you should pick for that particular location. Do you need to do canopy work during harvest? It's all those questions and those little minute details you're confronted with every harvest. Net, net, after almost fifty years, I feel I almost know less now than I did when I started.
13.What were you taught that you've since stopped doing?
Maybe this. I was a weather freak for probably the first twenty-five-plus years. I would look at every single model. We actually had access to some expensive weather models, and I would really, really stress over them. I don't stress about weather anymore. It's going to be pretty much what it is. It's out of my control. I just have to pull on whatever experience I've had under those conditions in the past. I don't look more than ten days out anymore, because I've found weather can change dramatically after those ten days. I just don't stress like I used to.
14.Is there a tank or a piece of equipment around here that has a name?
We have one of those very expensive presses that's Ferrari red, so I do call it my Ferrari, my red wine press. Jeff has a metal thief that somebody gave him decades ago. We don't have a name for it, but we should. He's never lost it and he still uses it. It's a heavy metal thief, so it doesn't break like a glass one. We need to get a name for that.
15.When someone who knows nothing about wine walks in, what do they already know that you can build on?
We all have our own set of senses, and wine is a subject where you're using all five of them to evaluate it and, hopefully, enjoy it. So it's getting that person more comfortable with their five senses, what they're perceiving, what they like and what they don't like, and getting them into a comfort zone where they can start relying on themselves and their senses and not on everybody else's.
How many times have I sat down with somebody who's enjoyed good food most of their life, and certainly opened a lot of good bottles of wine, and the first thing they say to me is, "I'm not a connoisseur, but..." And I try to tell them, "Yes, you are. You understand good food, and you've opened and appreciated a lot of good wines. You're as much a connoisseur as somebody who's writing about this stuff."
16.When someone pours your wine for a stranger, what do they need to know that isn't in the tasting notes?
There's always so much. The backstories on the wine, why you picked those blocks. I'm thinking about that question now in a fresh way. What are the relationships behind that wine? What's the relationship between the grower and the producer? What battles did the winemaker have to go through to get it into the bottle the way it is, that he or she will never write about? All those amazing backstories. Some are complimentary and some aren't. If you really wanted to, you could write a small book on every wine you make.
I think that was the case when I started fifty years ago, too. You'd go into a tasting room, and the winemaker or the owner, and sometimes they were the same person, would walk out to the counter and pour you some wines. They wouldn't charge you a dollar for the tasting. They'd talk to you about the wines. It was those stories and those encounters that really stoked the fires of our interest in wine, and it certainly wasn't the facts, the pH, the TA, or whatever of the wine.
17.What would someone have to watch you do to understand this wine?
There are so many parts to that. One could be simply putting together the final wine. Sometimes the wine comes to you complete. You try to change it, you think you could tweak it better, and it remains the same. Sometimes a wine comes to you and you work for a year and a half trying to find a better pathway.
What I found early on is that putting together a final wine, a final blend, is sometimes counterintuitive instead of intuitive. You'll have maybe a Petit Verdot or a Cabernet Franc you want to fit in, and intellectually you say, yeah, it's going to work, because that wine needs that element. You put it in, and it makes it worse. Other times you think, okay, I've got fat on fat with this blend, when it should be fat with a little bit of leanness to give it some dimension, and the fat on fat works. I've just found that great winemaking, and the pieces that come together, can be very counterintuitive, and it's hard for someone to embrace that if they're just getting into making wine.
18.What's your favorite wine that you don't make?
So many. But I did see that question. I'm making Martha's Vineyard now, and I'm writing up some copy for our first Martha's, which is 2025. So I put down the 1968 and 1974 Heitz Martha's Vineyard.
19.When you make a great one, do you know right away?
That's an interesting question. I think yes, you know you've got an exceptional wine. We talked about 2018. When we made the '18s, we said that. But sometimes, and the '16s and '11s are a classic case, with time they surprise you even more. So you get an idea. You can say, yeah, this is going to be an excellent wine. But how it fits in the pantheon of all the wines you've made really comes later.
20.One pour, one stranger. Which wine, and what do you say before they taste it?
It's funny. I was going to walk past that question, but then I thought about one wine that fit it, and it would be the 2016 that ended up as Black Magic. It's a good story about Jeff, my winemaker. We were getting some Petit Verdot and Cabernet together for the first time from Vine Hill Ranch, a great vineyard, a great site, and good growers. The Petit Verdot and the Cabernet came to the winery the same day, and Jeff says, "I want to put them in the same tank." I said, okay, what's the percentage? And Jeff said 40/60. He wanted 40 percent Petit Verdot. I said, come on, Jeff, no one does that. There's a lot of money tied up here. I can't do that.
He kept hounding me to do it. He even got a few other winemakers to get in touch with me and try to break my opinion. So I finally caved in. We're family owned, and we don't have anybody else who has to get involved in these decisions, so I could make it unilaterally, and we did it. The wine turned out to be one of the most amazing wines we've ever made, and it still is today. It's unlike anything I've ever tasted. It became my favorite wine of the vintage, and it became Black Magic, which was our signature wine and still is. Every time I open a bottle of it, which I'm fortunate to do because people open it for me as I move around, I'm just awed. It continues to evolve in ways unlike anything I've ever made.
One more: What does this work take away from you that people don't see?
Time. I think if you're doing it right, it's an industry that demands a huge amount of your time. Any owner, producer, or winemaker who doesn't get that will be, I think, greatly handicapped over time in building a brand or a label. It takes up far more of a person's time than most people realize when they're just getting into the business. If you're not willing to give that time, which means you have to give up other things that require time and balance the whole thing out, it can become ugly. So yeah, time is a bit of a vampire for a winemaker.
Recorded on Zoom on November 18, 2026, and edited lightly for length and clarity. Tor reviewed the piece before publication.
Patrick R. Dunn trained in narrative at the University of Maine and spent thirty years leading global crisis management and operational resilience teams across four continents, through 9/11, Katrina, and Sandy. He spent more than a decade as a National Park Service interpretive ranger and is WSET Level 3 certified. Through his practice, Vianarra, he works with winery owners, boutique hotels, and restaurants on how they tell their story. He writes about wine and hospitality every week at newsletter.vianarra.com.